We know how difficult choosing your main gear can be.
As if SO many backpack brands and models aren't already making picking the right one super difficult, there are different volume options for almost every model!
We were also sick of it.
To unveil the absolute winner, we took 20+ most popular backpacking backpacks in today's outdoor world and compared them according to their comfort, versatility, organization, durability and weight while also including all the other factors you'll see below.
- #A sidenote here: REI's backpack capacity chart is GOLD. Highly recommend you to check it out before you read any further.
Osprey Atmos 50 and 65, Osprey Aether 70, Osprey Exos 48 and 58, Osprey Kestrel 38 and 48, Osprey Levity 45 and 60, Osprey Talon 33 and 44, Osprey Xenith 105, Gossamer Gear Mariposa, Gossamer Gear Gorilla, HMG 2400 Southwest, ULA Circuit, ZPacks Arc Blast, Ultralight Adventure Equipment Ohm 2.0, Ultralight Adventure Equipment Circuit, Granite Gear Virga 2, REI Co-op Flash 45 and 65, REI Co-op Traverse 70, Gregory Baltoro 75, Gregory Paragon 68, Deuter Act Lite 65+10, The North Face Banchee 65, Kelty Coyote 65, Kelty Redwing 44 and 50, Thule Versant 70, Teton Sports Scout 3400 and 4000
In this post, we'll get down to the nitty gritty of the top 7. But before we bless you with the sweetest overview table y'all been waiting for... Let's reveal the winner of our huge study beforehand...
*Drum roll*...
In the end, we think that Osprey Atmos AG 65 | No products found. is the best overall backpacking backpack you can buy in 2019. It can be used for literally any outdoor activity due to its superior suspension performance demonstrated with a variety of loads.
Fit-on-the-fly hipbelt provides a secondary lid inside the belt and hence exceptional adjustability for any waist size. The only thing we didn't really like is that hip belt makes noise while walking with the pack as a result of its sturdy structure. B07GTFY4L7 No products found. No products found.
But before you make up your mind, let's make sure you looked at all the facts.
- Bold are my top picks for each group (based on trip length).
- If you tend to pack more or less than the average person, then shift the trip length values accordingly.
- If you're planning to get either one of them, I'd also highly recommend you to check out Osprey's own PackFinder tool as well.
To see the full table and my top picks, visit my post Best Osprey Hiking Backpacks.
Rotate your phone sideways for a better table display.
| Comfort | Features & Organization | Weight (M Size) |
---|---|---|---|
Trip Length: 7+ nights [>90 L] | |||
10/10 | 10/10 | 5.78 lbs | |
Cell | Trip Length: 5-7 nights [75 - 90 L] | ||
10/10 | 10/10 | 5.61 lbs | |
8/10 | 9/10 | 5.37 lbs | |
Cell | Trip Length: 2-5 nights [55 - 75 L] Sweet spot. Versatile picks. | ||
10/10 | 8/10 | 4.56 lbs | |
9/10 | 10/10 | 5.56 lbs | |
8/10 | 6/10 | 4.3 lbs | |
10/10 | 4/10 | 3.94 lbs | |
9/10 | 9/10 | 5.21 lbs | |
9/10 | 9/10 | 5.15 lbs | |
Volt 60 (Men's) | 8/10 | 6/10 | 4.3 lbs |
6/10 | 5/10 | 3.52 lbs | |
8/10 | 4/10 | 1.95 lbs | |
7/10 | 4/10 | 2.58 lbs | |
Cell | Trip Length: 1-3 nights [45 - 55 L] | ||
9/10 | 7/10 | 4.21 lbs | |
8/10 | 8/10 | 3.59 lbs | |
8/10 | 8/10 | 3.68 lbs | |
8/10 | 4/10 | 1.85 lbs | |
7/10 | 4/10 | 2.57 lbs | |
6/10 | 6/10 | 3.49 lbs | |
Viva 50 (Women's) | 8/10 | 6/10 | 4.02 lbs |
Cell | Trip Length: 0-1 nights [<45 L] | ||
8/10 | 8/10 | 3.40 lbs | |
8/10 | 8/10 | 3.30 lbs | |
8/10 | 6/10 | 2.44 lbs | |
9/10 | 5/10 | 2.02 lbs | |
8/10 | 4/10 | 2.48 lbs |
If you're interested in getting a travel backpack, check out my Osprey's top travel backpacks post.
Overview
Turn your phone sideways for optimal table display!
Overall Score | |||||||
This product is a Crunch Top Pick! | |||||||
Osprey Atmos AG 65 | Gregory Baltoro 65 | Osprey Aether AG 70 | Deuter Act Lite 65+10 | Osprey Kestrel 48 | Kelty Redwing 50 | Teton Sports Scout 3400 | |
Pros | Exceptional adjustability, suspension system and 3 size options provide unbeatable fit and comfort Incredible ventilation, integrated rain cover and optimal volume ensure extreme versatility Very durable Stylish design | Hefty structure carries heavy loads very well Attached rain cover Top AND front accesses to main compartment | Convertible top lid daypack Extremely well designed for carrying heavy loads Top AND front accesses to main compartment | Abundant padding keeps your hips and back at ease Very close fit takes load off your shoulders even at a whooping full 75L of items Very light for its huge volume | Lightweight Comfortable back panel and shoulder straps Innovative side pocket More likely to be accepted as carry on | Unique design provides well ventilation and innovative organization Lightest pack in top 7 Innovative tool attachment capability | External hydration sleeve Integrated rain cover adds to the versatility |
Osprey Atmos AG 65 | Gregory Baltoro 65 | Osprey Aether AG 70 | Deuter Act Lite 65+10 | Osprey Kestrel 48 | Kelty Redwing 50 | Teton Sports Scout 3400 | |
Cons | Hip belt makes noise while walking with the pack as a result of its sturdy structure | On the heavier side Convertible summit pack is very rudimentarywith limited comfort | Wobbles when not full Relatively heavy | Relatively less pockets Lacking ventilation One size fits all | Can come small for most of extended (3+ days) trips | Not specifically designed for trail Can come small for most of extended (3+ days) trips One size fits all | Zippers feel unwieldy due to solid durable structure Not very easy to use |
Best for | Those who are looking for the best overall backpacking backpack | Those who will be packing heavy and don't need as many features as Osprey Aether 70 | Those who are looking for a very cool, feature rich pack specifically designed for carrying heavy loads | Those who prefer more room and won't be backpacking in too hot/cold weather | Those who are looking for a very comfortable medium capacity trail backpack with a lean towards traveling | Those who are looking for a do it all backpack | Beginner backpackers who don't need a premium pack and would do equally fine with a more balanced item |
Osprey Atmos AG 65 | Gregory Baltoro 65 | Osprey Aether AG 70 | Deuter Act Lite 65+10 | Osprey Kestrel 48 | Kelty Redwing 50 | Teton Sports Scout 3400 | |
Comfort Versatility Organization Suspension Weight | |||||||
PRODUCT SPECS | |||||||
Osprey Atmos AG 65 | Gregory Baltoro 65 | Osprey Aether AG 70 | Deuter Act Lite 65+10 | Osprey Kestrel 48 | Kelty Redwing 50 | Teton Sports Scout 3400 | |
Dimensions: 34.25H X 15.35W X 16.14D IN Weight: 4.56 lbs Volume: 65L | Dimensions: 25.2H x 15.0W x 9.5D IN Weight: 5.5 lbs Volume: 65L | Dimensions: 33.46H X 15.75W X 13.39D IN Weight: 5.21 lbs Volume: 70L | Dimensions: 33.86H x 14.17W x 12.6D IN Weight: 4.39 lbs Volume: 65L | Dimensions: 28H X 15W X 16D IN Weight: 3.68 lbs Volume: 48L | Dimensions: 26H X 16W X 12D IN Weight: 3.11 lbs Volume: 50L | Dimensions: 30H X 17W X 12D IN Weight: 4.5 lbs Volume: 55L | |
#Note: As you see, dimensions and volumes don't really add up. See our post Dimensional Inconsistencies of Osprey Backpacks (also applies to non-Osprey packs) to read more. But the short answer is that backpacks are made of pliable materials and hence their volume can't be measured like boxes. Stated volumes are accurate. | |||||||
User manual | N/A | N/A | N/A | N/A | |||
Women's counterpart | N/A |
1- Osprey Atmos AG 65
Among tens of backpacks, Osprey's Atmos AG 65 is single handedly the best backpacking pack we tested mainly because of its unbeatable comfort and very well thought out organizational features.
Comfort and Suspension
The state of the art technology of Osprey, the AntiGravity (AG) suspension system, makes a perfect job keeping the Atmos AG 65 close to your body. Mesh foam and generous padding throughout the entire shoulder straps, hip belt and back panel feels very pleasant especially on your shoulders.
And with a very close fit you always sacrifice ventilation. Right?
Wrong!
Atmos AG 65 turned out to be the MOST ventilated pack in the contest with its AG system and breathable mesh throughout the back panel.
You might like our in-depth Osprey Atmos AG vs Aether AG comparison!
In the end, exceptional adjustability and suspension of Atmos AG 65 helps you walk longer distances more comfortably without the extra exhaustion and sweat.
Versatility, Organization and Weight
Although the most powerful aspect of Atmos AG 65 is its superior suspension performance demonstrated with a variety of loads, it's also quite versatile even though it has less features than Aether AG 70.
- Stretch mesh front pouch for any dirty, wet or smelly items,
- Stow-on-the-Go trekking pole attachment for stowing your trekking poles without having to take off the pack,
- FlapJacket for lidless use when you want to cut back on weight,
- Its relatively light weight at 4.56 pounds,
- Optimal 65L of volume,
- Integrated rain cover with the most recent 2018 model,
- Internal AND external top lid zippered pockets for easy access to the frequently used items
- Sleeping bag compartment and hence secondary access
- Loops and bungee tie-offs for external ice axe attachment
- Sleeping pad straps
As for durability, even though the zippers, buckles, suspension system and 100D x 630D Nylon material of Atmos AG 65 stay just as new after years of use (like any other Osprey pack); it's still a relief to know that Osprey's All Mighty Guarantee has got your back just in case of any issues for any reason.
We've never been very kind to their packs and experienced literally zero problems so far.
No products found.
2- Gregory Baltoro 65
This pack scored the highest in the organization department with its excellent pockets, features and multiple accesses to the main compartment. Robust suspension is extremely well designed to carry heavy loads and is now lighter with the updated 2018 model which is reviewed here.
Comfort and Suspension
Although the super robust suspension might feel somewhat too rigid putting on Baltoro 65 the first time, it feels extremely comfortable in the long run. While hauling heavy (40+ lbs) it performed even better than the overall most comfortable pack Atmos AG 65 in this roundup.
With lumbar pad silicon overlay slippage is prevented and pack stayed more stable than other packs in this review, while ventilation was average.
Versatility, Organization and Weight
This pack truly excels in terms of pocket organization and is the most feature rich pack in this review along with Aether AG 70.
See our free Step by Step Guide: How to Pack a Backpack (Bonus: Hiking Checklist!)
Baltoro 65 is water resistant, but not waterproof. Rain cover (included with the sale) comes inside the internal top lid zippered mesh pocket fits around the pack perfectly. We preferred storing rain cover inside the main compartment and used the mesh pocket for the items aren't needed until the hike ends e.g car keys, wallet and earphones.
Right hip belt pocket is waterproof and designed to make electronics such as GPS and smart phones readily available. Though it's somewhat smaller and an iPhone 6/7/8 Plus would have a hard time fitting inside. Left zippered mesh hip belt pocket is great for snacks.
When hydration sleeve inside the pack is removed it transforms to a tiny sidekick backpack. Sleeping pad straps at the front bottom of pack can be removed and attached to the sidekick pack as waist belt.
Despite this perfect organization, if you still desperately need something at the middle of the pack, no need to worry. You don't have to dig through all the items from top or bottom opening since U-shaped front access makes all your items inside the main compartment easily accessible - which we found extremely useful.
Finally, there are plenty of external attachment loops to carry more gear such as sleeping pad, ice axe and trekking poles.
In the end, Gregory Baltoro 65 is an excellent heavy hauling pack with tons of features which allow using it during a very broad range of activities.
No products found.
3- Osprey Aether AG 70
This pack is absolutely the best choice for those who'll be hiking with lots of heavy items. In other words; those who'll be hiking mostly with their kids, pets, during the winter or for very long time (5+ days).
Comfort and Suspension
Aether AG 70 felt very similar to Gregory Baltoro 65 in terms of comfort and suspension. At heavier weights (40+ pounds), Aether AG 70 feels more comfortable than any other pack we tested, including Baltoro 65.
Our only problem with Aether AG 70 suspension was that due to hard-framed, rigid peripheral frame specifically designed to carry heavy loads, when not full and relatively lighter, it wobbles and loses out on comfort.
Adjustability of Aether AG 70 is similar to other packs: a velcro attached to the back panel offers harness slippage and adjusting to torso height accordingly. What makes this pack stand out is the 4 different size options available to ensure even further fit.
Versatility, Organization and Weight
Along with Baltoro 65, Aether AG 70 is the most feature rich product in this review.
Most convertible daypacks (also referred as summit pack or sidekick backpack) seem like a very cool idea in theory but fail hard in practice. On the other hand, when you remove the top lid of Aether AG 70 and unzip the top pocket; it transforms into a legit, super comfortable daypack with two different compartments and external gear attachment loops. Far better than the sidekick backpack of Gregory Baltoro 65.
IsoForm custom heat moldable hip-belt is heated and molded to your hips at a CM Certified Osprey dealer anywhere nearby. We're told that remold is possible up to 3 times due to drastic bodyweight changes but honestly any hip belt of any pack is compressed and molded to your hips naturally - molding method is just to speed up the process and a demanding one. You'd be completely fine skipping it as well.
See our in-depth Osprey Atmos AG vs Aether AG comparison!
We found the rare feature front access to the main compartment very useful when you need an item stuck in the middle. We had zero problems with many external gear attachment loops, buckles, zips and compression straps. Mesh water bottle holders at sides allow horizontal installment as well (in addition to vertical installment) allowing stowing without having to take off the pack.
In the end, this pack excels in terms of features, organizational capacity and heavy hauling performance. For durability, it's a true relief to know that Osprey's All Mighty Guarantee has got your back just in case of any issues for any reason. Now you can stop worrying about the pack completely and enjoy your time outdoors!
No products found.
4- Deuter ACT Lite 65+10
If you're that person prefers more room over organizational pockets and features, Deuter ACT Lite 65+10 can be a great choice for you.
Comfort and Suspension
Well German-engineered harness and suspension provides premium comfort especially on the ridiculously stout hip belt. It covers all your waist and distributes the load effectively to your hips. As a result your waist feels like leaning against the cushion of a business class Emirates flight seat.
Harness adjustment to correspond the optimal torso height worked extremely well as it offers more than 10" of adjustment. Still, we'd like to see different size options available for further customized fit (like that of Atmos AG 65).
Since it's universal size and must fit everyone from 5' to 6'4", the straps are ridiculously long and flap around unless you're on the taller side.
Versatility, Organization and Weight
This pack has all the must-have and none of nice-to-have pockets.
With the updated 2018 model, now the lid is removable when you need to save weight and it does float to accept more loading when needed. Top lid pockets are standard - an external and an internal - both zippered. Although they both provide more room than other packs in this contest, sleeping bag compartment offers less, but still is perfectly fine to store even a bear canister.
Stretch mesh pouch at the front can be used for any smelly, dirty and/or wet items.
Main design intentions of this pack are mountaineering and trekking, but it's also a perfect travelling companion. At only 4.39 lbs, it's quite light for its huge 75 liters build while staying very durable against our super cruel treatment.
No products found.
References
- Osprey: All Might Guarantee. Retrieved from https://www.osprey.com/cl/en/customer-support/all-mighty-guarantee
- Carry-on Size Chart, 170+ Airlines, Travel-made-simple.com. Retrieved from https://travel-made-simple.com/carry-on-size-chart/
- Epstein, Yoram et al. (2017). Mitigating load carriage burden – The Dynamic Weight Distribution (DWD) hip belt. Journal of Science and Medicine in Sport, Volume 20, S101. Retrieved from http://www.jsams.org/article/S1440-2440(17)31506-2/pdf
- Osprey. Size & Fit. Retrieved from https://www.osprey.com/ca/en/fitting-learning/size-fit
- McGill, L. How to Tell if I Have a Long or Short Torso, Healthfully.com. Retrieved from https://healthfully.com/tell-long-short-torso-8251478.html
- Hawbaker, A. (2015, July). TrailTime Tips: Daisy Chain Quick Ties. Retrieved from https://www.rei.com/learn/expert-advice/backpacks-adjusting-fit.html
Guide: Backpacks
Start here:
Complete list:
- Osprey Atmos AG 50
- Osprey Atmos AG 65
- Osprey Aura AG 50
- Osprey Aura AG 65
- Osprey Aether AG 60
- Osprey Aether AG 70
- Osprey Aether AG 85
- Osprey Aether PRO 70
- Osprey Ariel AG 55
- Osprey Ariel AG 65
- Osprey Ariel AG 75
- Osprey Ariel PRO 65
- Osprey Xenith 75, 88 & 105
- Gregory Baltoro 65, 75, 85, 95 PRO
- Osprey Kestrel 38
- Osprey Kestrel 48
- Osprey Kyte 36
- Osprey Kyte 46
- Kelty Redwing 50
- Teton Sports Scout 3400
david C. says
Great article. Best I read. Helped me decide between Osprey Atmos and Kestrel. Thanks!