• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

OutdoorCrunch

  • BASICS
  • PRO TIPS
  • GEAR
    • JACKETS
      • INSULATED JACKETS
        • DOWN JACKETS
        • SYNTHETIC INSULATED JACKETS
      • SHELL JACKETS
        • HARDSHELL JACKETS
        • SOFTSHELL JACKETS
      • SKI JACKETS
      • PARKAS
      • RAIN JACKETS
      • WIND JACKETS
      • FLEECE JACKETS
    • BACKPACKS
    • COOKING
      • BACKPACKING STOVES
      • COOKWARE
    • FOOTWEAR
  • MISCELLANEOUS
  • ABOUT
    • ABOUT ME
    • CONTACT
  • PRIVACY POLICY
Home / Gear

ABOUT ME
Hey, what's up? Canberk here. A former General Electric Aviation Design Engineer. Academically involved in cold weather outdoor gear, particularly wearable heating systems using conductive polyester and polyamide yarns. Read more about me. 

Altra Timp vs Lone Peak

Last updated: July 21, 2022 by Canberk Koksal

  • Max event distances for each Altra trail running shoe can pull off without making you feel uncomfortable...

 

Miles / km's 

Cushion

Bottom line

 

Olympus 4.0 (Men's - Women's)

75+/120+

High

Best for super long hours of standing, walking, hiking or trail running.

Read Review

Timp 2.0 (Men's - Women's)

75/120

Avg-high

2-in-1 one: Trail running and backpacking.

Read Review

Lone Peak 4.5 (Men's - Women's)

50/80

Avg

Safest bet. Closest you get to a typical running shoe anatomy, versatile.

Read Review

Superior 4.5 (Men's - Women's)

30/50

Avg-low

More of a minimalist, performance shoe.

Read Review

King MT 2.0 (Men's - Women's)

10/16

Low

Really performance oriented pick.

 

These are only approximate values assuming typical settings. If you think you;

  • Are heavier than the average person,
  • Relatively less conditioned for longer runs,
  • Will mostly be running on trails more rocky than average, etc...

...then always opt for the more cushioned option when in doubt.

  • REI is on a rare sale. Don't miss. Patagonia's are like up to 70% off... 
    • https://www.rei.com/h/deals
We review and compare Altra's Timp and Lone Peak trail running shoes.

Altra Lone Peak 4.5's in their natural habitat.

A short answer first:

The most important difference is the extra cushioning the Timp 2.0 offers over the Lone Peak 4.5's.

A summary around the cushioning:

  • The Lone Peak is the closest you can get to a typical running shoe anatomy: Average cushioning, and hence also average underfoot protection and average ground feel. It's your safest bet.
  • The Timp, on the other hand, is more cushioned than the Lone Peak, but not by a huge amount - so the ground feel is sacrificed just slightly in return, and the underfoot protection is ended up being a little superior.

Lastly, this Grey/Blue color of Timp 2.0 and this Gray/Orange color of Lone Peak 4.5 are the most preferred color combinations. 

  • Both the Lone Peak and Timp got revised during late 2019!

I've also published posts regarding the changes going from Lone Peak 4.0 to 4.5, and the changes going from Timp 1.5 to Timp 2.0. So check them out if you're considering the previous versions.

I also contacted the Altra Customer Service about this, and shared the chat history at the bottom of this post, but the information given until that part also includes all the Rep's worth mentioning comments.

Altra Timp 1.5's.

Cushioning

Cushioning is an objective parameter, and the winner is clearly the Timp in this department.

If you were to line up all 5 Altra trail running shoes by the amount of their cushioning, Lone Peak's would be right in the middle.

And the Timp's, having a little more cushioning than the Lone Peak's, would be placed right next to the them.

So how does this cushion difference play out in practice?

If you're either:

  • Quite a bit on the heavier side (say, more than 190 lbs),
  • New to running/hiking,
  • Running/hiking on a relatively more rough and/or rocky trails,
  • Planning to run/hike mostly for long distances,
  • Prioritize underfoot protection and cushion over the ground feel,
  • Wishing to go easier on your joints (for any reason),
  • Not really wishing much traction...

...then the extra cushion in the Timp's are highly likely to make a positive difference for you - but not by a huge amount, because the Lone Peak's are also equipped with a fair amount of cushion.

Traction

This was my main beef with the Timp 1.5's, and it certainly is improved in Timp 2.0, but Lone Peak 4.5's are still a little bit superior in this department.

The traction performance of the Lone Peaks 4.5's isn't exceptional either, (especially when you consider a trail running shoe with mad traction capabilities such as this one), it's still noticeably better than the Timp's.

Outsole base of the Timp 1.5 (at the top) could have really used a more aggressively rough surface to ensure better traction - which most users also complained about. Seems like Altra heard of this and decided to update the Timp 2.0 from DuraTrac to MaxTrac.

So called "DuraTrac" traction technology of Timp 1.5 is outdated as of 2020 - especially compared to the "MaxTrac" traction technology of most recently updated Altra trail running shoes, including the Lone Peak 4.5's.

But still, although the outsole technology of the Timp 2.0 seem to catch up with the Lone Peak 4.5, due to the stack height it's still more prone to slippage.


First cushioning, and second traction performance is really how you should base your decision primarily off when having a dilemma between Timp's and Lone Peak's.

So I'd recommend you to make your decision based on this chart:

  • Max event distances for each Altra trail running shoe can pull off without making you feel uncomfortable...

 

Miles / km's 

Cushion

Bottom line

 

Olympus 4.0 (Men's - Women's)

75+/120+

High

Best for super long hours of standing, walking, hiking or trail running.

Read Review

Timp 2.0 (Men's - Women's)

75/120

Avg-high

2-in-1 one: Trail running and backpacking.

Read Review

Lone Peak 4.5 (Men's - Women's)

50/80

Avg

Safest bet. Closest you get to a typical running shoe anatomy, versatile.

Read Review

Superior 4.5 (Men's - Women's)

30/50

Avg-low

More of a minimalist, performance shoe.

Read Review

King MT 2.0 (Men's - Women's)

10/16

Low

Really performance oriented pick.

 

These are only approximate values assuming typical settings. If you think you;

  • Are heavier than the average person,
  • Relatively less conditioned for longer runs,
  • Will mostly be running on trails more rocky than average, etc...

...then always opt for the more cushioned option when in doubt.

Now let's talk about some other relatively minor things to consider.

Underfoot protection & durability

Due to the extra cushion, all the Timp revisions will offer greater underfoot protection than all the Lone Peak revisions.

Fit

The Lone Peak 4.5's fit slightly narrower compared to the Timp 2.0's in the upper. Width of the soles are the same (as it's with all the Altra shoes).

As far as the size are concerned, though, they both size up as expected.

Conclusion

If you're either:

  1. Quite a bit on the heavier side (say, more than 190 lbs),
  2. New to running/hiking,
  3. Running/hiking on a relatively more rough and/or rocky trails,
  4. Planning to run/hike mostly for long distances,
  5. Prioritize underfoot protection and cushion over the ground feel,
  6. Wishing to go easier on your joints (for any reason),
  7. Not really wishing much traction...

...then Timp 2.0's can be a really good choice. If your situation doesn't tick these boxes much, than Lone Peak 4.5's can be a great choice.

No products found.

ALTRA Men's ALM1957F TIMP 1.5 Trail Running Shoe
ALTRA Men's ALM1957F TIMP 1.5 Trail Running Shoe
Buy on Amazon
ALTRA Women's ALW1957F TIMP 1.5 Trail Running Shoe
ALTRA Women's ALW1957F TIMP 1.5 Trail Running Shoe
Buy on Amazon

Also, here are two good video reviews:

For Lone Peak 4.5:

For Timp 2.0:

  • Altra King MT
  • Altra Superior 4.0
  • Altra Lone Peak 4.0
  • Altra Lone Peak 4.5
  • Altra Timp 1.5
  • Altra Timp 2.0
  • Altra Olympus 3.5
  • Altra Olympus 4.0

Filed Under: Footwear, Gear Tagged With: altra, altra footwear, altra running footwear, altra trail running footwear, footwear

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. Pekka Matilainen says

    October 10, 2020 at 5:25 pm

    What about the comments from Altra Customer Service?

  2. David Seals says

    February 25, 2021 at 5:07 am

    I have been wearing Altra Lone Peaks 2 & 3, and Timps 1, 1.5, and 2s for about 5 years now. I have had about 12 pairs. Although I absolutely love them and find them to be the most comfortable shoe available, I am in the process of looking for another company until they can make a shoe with a sole that I can get more miles out of. 4 pairs of Altras this year is just unacceptable. I literally can’t afford to keep wearing them. I love the shoes but hate the lack of durability. I have another pair, (Solomons) that are almost as comfortable, offer slightly more protection and last at least twice as long, maybe 3 times longer. I hope Altra works to fix this because I really like their product but the honeymoon is over.

Primary Sidebar

Crunch Search

About me

Hey, what's up? Canberk here. A former General Electric Aviation Design Engineer. Academically involved in cold weather outdoor gear, particularly wearable heating systems using conductive polyester and polyamide yarns. Read more about me.

  • Email
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • LinkedIn

Featured Posts

  • Temperature Ratings of Insulated Jackets
  • Best Arc’teryx Jackets
  • Best Patagonia Jackets

  • Newsletter
Sign up

I rarely send mails. 

window.dataLayer = window.dataLayer || []; function gtag(){dataLayer.push(arguments);} gtag('js', new Date()); gtag('config', 'G-GDD0YD30SK');

  • BASICS
  • PRO TIPS
  • GEAR
  • MISCELLANEOUS
  • ABOUT
  • PRIVACY POLICY
We review and compare Altra's Timp and Lone Peak trail running shoes.
Altra Timp 1.5's in action!
We review and compare Altra's Timp and Lone Peak trail running shoes.
Altra Timp 1.5's in action!