• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

OutdoorCrunch

  • BASICS
  • PRO TIPS
  • GEAR
    • JACKETS
      • INSULATED JACKETS
        • DOWN JACKETS
        • SYNTHETIC INSULATED JACKETS
      • SHELL JACKETS
        • HARDSHELL JACKETS
        • SOFTSHELL JACKETS
      • SKI JACKETS
      • PARKAS
      • RAIN JACKETS
      • WIND JACKETS
      • FLEECE JACKETS
    • BACKPACKS
    • COOKING
      • BACKPACKING STOVES
      • COOKWARE
    • FOOTWEAR
  • MISCELLANEOUS
  • ABOUT
    • ABOUT ME
    • CONTACT
  • PRIVACY POLICY

Backpacks

Osprey Exos 48 vs 58

Last updated: June 8, 2022 by Canberk Koksal

Exos 58. 

We will get to compare Exos 48 vs 58. 

But before we do that, in order for you to be able to compare and then choose between them correctly, you must first understand how Exos/Eja packs are positioned in Osprey's entire ocean of backpacks. 

That said, if you'd like to hear a short answer from me, then here it is: 

I'd recommend you to make your decision around trip length. Get the Exos 48 for backpacking trips of 3 days tops and the 58 for 5 days tops. There's no difference between them rather than the volume. 

Now let's get to the bolts and nuts. 

Is Exos really the line you're looking for?

I want you to read this because Exos appeals to a rather narrower percentage of audience.

  • #A sidenote here: REI's backpack capacity chart is GOLD. Highly recommend you to check it out before you read any further. 
Along with Levity/Lumina, Exos/Eja line is Osprey's one of two light backpacking backpack lines. 

The former is lighter (and hence, the lightest), whereas the latter is equipped with more organizational features and is more durable; at the expense of some weight (around 0.6 lbs (270 grams), depending on selected size). So, Exos/Eja is positioned closer to a typical backpack anatomy. 

Exos 48. 

If this design intention doesn't really respond to your own needs and desires, or in other words, if you don't pack ultralight gear but typical stuff; then you should probably stop reading and forget about getting either of Exos/Eja 48 and 58. 

Because I'm 100% sure there's another Osprey Backpack out there that responds perfectly even to the narrowest type of audience. They niche down to so many purposes it might actually freak you out. 

So if you aren't an ultralighter, I'd recommend you to check out my Osprey Exos vs Atmos post.

If you are an ultralighter, though; then keep reading. 

Volume: Should you get the 48 or 58? 

Exos 58. 

38 is too small for backpacking anyway - only day hiking. 

Exos is rather a streamlined piece:

  • Consists of main compartment only (no sleeping compartment), 
  • Offers top access only (no bottom or mid access), 
  • Only 3 exterior pockets, 
  • Lid can be removed to save some weight. 

There's no difference between 48 and 58 rather than volume. 

And most of that volume is carried out within the main compartments of each pack. 

Which means that they aren't one of those packs trying to trick you into believing they're actually larger than they really are by putting their large pockets into play to exaggerate their technical specs section. 

Load capability ranges of these packs are also the same: 20-40 lbs. If you try to push this further, you will notice better results with the 58 due to its larger frame, though. 

Like I said earlier into the post, get the Exos 48 for backpacking trips of 3 days tops and the 58 for 5 days tops. 

If you aren't an ultralighter, I wouldn't recommend you to get either of them and instead to check out my Osprey Exos vs Atmos post. 

Filed Under: Backpacks Tagged With: backpacks, osprey, osprey backpacking backpacks

Osprey Aether/Ariel 60/55 vs 70/65 vs 85/75 [or PRO?]

Last updated: June 8, 2022 by Canberk Koksal

How large is Aether AG 70. 

What you'll learn from this post: Whether you should get an Aether 60, 70, 85 or PRO 70; or an Ariel AG 55, 65, 75 or PRO 65 (women's counterparts). 

As you know, besides Arc'teryx Jackets, I review and admire Osprey Backpacks (full list at the bottom) the most here in this site, so I'm usually asked a lot of questions. 

Osprey backpacks, especially Aether/Ariel AG Line, are far from cheap, so I'd encourage you to read this short (3-4 min) post entirely.

But if you desperately want a short answer:

I'd recommend the Aether AG 70 (or Ariel AG 65) over the 55/60/75/85 to most of you. It's also quite pretty, and this Adirondack Green is really liked by many - including me. PRO would be an overkill unless either used for thru-hikes or alpine expeditions.

We'll get to the optimal volume you should pick, but in order to be able to compare them, I think you really need to understand their stance first in Osprey's entire product line, which hints their design intentions.

  • #A sidenote here: REI's backpack capacity chart is GOLD. Highly recommend you to check it out before you read any further. 

This will boost your chances of choosing the right volume for your own needs and desires.

But, if you don't want to hear this part out (although I think you should), navigate to "What is the perfect volume" heading from here:

Quick Navigation
Do you really need an Aether/Ariel?
So what is the perfect volume?
What about PRO?

Do you really need an Aether/Ariel?

As you can also (maybe) see in this chart I've put together:

Aether/Ariel AG Line isn't designed to perform very well in every backpacking activity (although it still does much better than average), but to excel in one thing: Extended trips and/or hauling heavy loads.

...which is why Osprey advertises them as mountaineering backpacks as well, in addition to as backpacking backpacks. They make an incredible job in both.

  • On the other hand, if you ARE looking for one that performs very well in every activity...

Then you should check out my Atmos/Aura 50/65 AG Review, not Aether/Ariel AG.

So, generally speaking, there are some specific conditions where an Aether/Ariel pack would pay off the most. These include but are not limited to:

Did I mention how perfect Aether/Ariel is for backpacking with pets? Obviously kidding, lol. I meant carrying the equipment of your pet.

  1. Thru-hikes,
  2. Alpine expeditions,
  3. Backpacking in winter, 
  4. 4-5+ day backpacking trips,
  5. Backpacking with kids/pets.

Typically, the first two items are better dealt with Aether/Ariel PRO 70/65, whereas the remaining three are handled by Aether AG 60/70/85 and Ariel AG 55/65/75.

So what makes Aether/Ariel AG Line a perfect match for these activities? 

  • Bulkier suspension that makes heavy hauling noticeably more comfortable,
  • Convertible top lid daypack (IMPORTANT: Available in US & Canada ONLY, but you can order this one),
  • A central access (through a side panel zip for 55/60 and a front J-zip for 65/70/75/85) to main compartment (Not available in PRO configurations).

As you can see in almost all my other posts, I'm a HUGE fan of Atmos/Aura AG 65 and I recommend it to anyone who's looking for the best backpacking backpack for basically everything.

  • How to distinguish a previous model of Aether/Ariel from the most recent one?

Click on image to enlarge. Pay attention to red squares (duh).

In other words, this one is the most recent model. Not this one.

If you find a good deal for the old Aether/Ariel, and you like the design, you can get it over the recent one. Updates are minor going from the old to recent model and likely won't make a noticeable difference in practice.

However, these 3 features Aether/Ariel AG Line offers (which, by the way, Atmos/Aura AG Line doesn't) are crucial for extended trips and/or hauling heavy loads, as you can also see in my Osprey Atmos vs Aether and Osprey Aura vs Ariel comparisons.

They'll save tons of time and frustration.


Now if you've read up to this point, you should know whether an Aether/Ariel AG would be a good option for your own needs and desires. 

Ariel AG 65.

And if you think you do, now it's time for you to make a decision for the volume.

So what is the perfect volume?

Some say the more space you have, the more you'll pack, but I don't think this is necessarily true for most of us.

Remember, not needing the extra volume but having it is always better than wishing some extra volume but not having it.

This is why I always recommend going for 10-15 L more than what you think you'll need. You never know what comes up.

As a rule of thumb, this corresponds to:

  • Aether AG 70 or Ariel AG 65 for up to 5 days of backpacking trips,
  • Aether AG 85 or Ariel AG 75 for more than 5 days of backpacking trips. It's HUGE.

Osprey Aether AG 70 Men's Backpacking Backpack
Osprey Aether AG 70 Men's Backpacking Backpack
(356)
Buy on Amazon
Osprey Ariel AG 65 Women's Backpacking Backpack (2020 Model)
Osprey Ariel AG 65 Women's Backpacking Backpack...
(94)
Buy on Amazon

See? Aether AG 85 is HUGE!

Yes, I didn't list Aether AG 60 and Ariel AG 55 here because I think they're somehow misplaced in Osprey's entire backpacking backpack line.

Aether AG 60 and Ariel AG 55 are still fantastic packs and the reason I don't recommend them stems from the superiority of the alternative option, Atmos/Aura Line; NOT from the inferiority of Aether AG 60 and Ariel AG 55.

Because, when you think about it, if you think you'd be able to get away with relatively small volume, then you probably wouldn't benefit aforementioned 3 unique features of Aether/Ariel AG that much anyway.

In that case, you'd probably be better getting an Osprey Atmos/Aura AG 65.

The only scenario I can think of where it'd make sense getting an Aether AG 60 or Ariel AG 55 over the Atmos/Aura AG 65 would probably be carrying lots of heavy items {more than, say, 50 lbs (23 kg) at total} and/or desperately needing a convertible daypack & central access to the main compartment.

In that heavy hauling case, relatively weak suspension of Atmos/Aura AG 65 might not cut it. So you might see a noticeable extra benefit with Aether AG 60 or Ariel AG 55.

Osprey Aether AG 60 Men's Backpacking Backpack (2020 Model)
Osprey Aether AG 60 Men's Backpacking Backpack...
Buy on Amazon
Osprey Aether AG 70 Men's Backpacking Backpack
Osprey Aether AG 70 Men's Backpacking Backpack
(356)
Buy on Amazon
Osprey Aether AG 85 Men's Backpacking Backpack
Osprey Aether AG 85 Men's Backpacking Backpack
Buy on Amazon

Osprey Ariel AG 55 Women's Backpacking Backpack
Osprey Ariel AG 55 Women's Backpacking Backpack
Buy on Amazon
Osprey Ariel AG 65 Women's Backpacking Backpack (2020 Model)
Osprey Ariel AG 65 Women's Backpacking Backpack...
(94)
Buy on Amazon
Osprey Ariel AG 75 Women's Backpacking Backpack
Osprey Ariel AG 75 Women's Backpacking Backpack
Buy on Amazon

What about PRO?

Like I said, you must have a solid reason to get a PRO.

Which is either thru-hikes, alpine expeditions, or falling love with its design. Otherwise it's most likely an overkill.

No products found.

Filed Under: Backpacks Tagged With: backpacks, osprey, osprey backpacking backpacks

Osprey Atmos/Aura 50 vs 65

Last updated: June 8, 2022 by Canberk Koksal

Atmos AG 65 is my top pick. 

As most of you know, I'm a huge fan of Osprey backpacks and talk about them a lot (full list at the bottom of this post). 

...especially about the Atmos/Aura line. 

...and especially about the AG 65. This is why I recommend it as the best multi-day Osprey backpacking backpack out there. 

Recently I get asked about Atmos AG 50 vs 65 and Aura AG 50 vs 65 (women's counterpart) a lot. So there we go. 

In summary: 

If you'll be doing a fair amount of backpacking trips longer than 2 nights, then I'd recommend the 65 liters (bonus: 2 extra front pockets). 

What's more, to be honest; top-notch construction of Atmos/Aura Series would probably be an overkill at 50 liters for most of us. This is why, even if you're convinced you need 50 liters, then I'd recommend Stratos 50 for men and Kyte 46 for women. 

  • #A sidenote here: REI's backpack capacity chart is GOLD. Highly recommend you to check it out before you read any further. 
If you'll be going to be backpacking Europe, Australia or South America (or any other place) for weeks/months, then I'd recommend you the 65 L version my eyes closed.

You'll love 2 extra front pockets as much as you love the additional 15 liters of volume.

You must have a GOOD reason to get the 50 L option. Some say the more space you have, the more you'll pack. But I don't think this is necessarily true for most of us.

This is why I'd only recommend the 50 L option over the 65 L option to those who won't be backpacking for anything longer than a night.

Osprey Packs Atmos AG 65 Men's Backpacking Backpack
Osprey Packs Atmos AG 65 Men's Backpacking...
(4)
Buy on Amazon
Osprey Aura AG 65 Women's Backpacking Backpack
Osprey Aura AG 65 Women's Backpacking Backpack
(377)
Buy on Amazon

What are the differences between Atmos/Aura AG 50 and 65?

Yes, the most important difference between them is the volume difference: 50 vs 65 - but this isn't the only difference as I mentioned above.

As you can also see in their manual here [PDF], you also get 2 extra front pockets with the AG 65 options of both Atmos and Aura - which in the end make more of your items readily available.

This is a life saver on longer trips.

Atmos AG 50. Lacks two front pockets.

Volume: How to decide?

Here's the way it's looked at:

  • 50 liters is considered as the sweet spot for backpacking trips up to 2-3 days.
  • 65 liters is sufficient up to a 5-6 days, or almost a week if you tend to pack very little. Then again, if you're an ultralighter, you'd probably better check out my Atmos vs Exos comparison rather than this post.

Now, putting this rule of thumb aside, I always recommend opting for a backpack with around 10-15 liters of more volume than you think you'll need.

  • As you might have already realized...

Dimensions and volumes of Osprey Packs reported in their product pages don't add up.

I contacted Osprey's customer service about this and laid out all my findings here in this post.

Because not needing the extra volume but having it is always better than wishing extra volume but not having it.

Two front pockets: How important are they?

Granted, the these pockets become more important when you're on a longer backpacking trip (or pack more stuff for any reason: Trips with kids or pets, winter hikes, etc.). Just like the volume.

After all, the entire point of these front pockets is to make more of your items readily available.

If you think you might need a pack with an even better organization, then check out Aether AG 70 and how it compares to the Atmos AG 65 (or Aura vs Ariel for women's).

  • You might also like this post...

How to pack a backpacking backpack & what to pack.

At the end of the day, not having to dig through your entire inventory when you need an item stuck somewhere in the middle of your pack will save you a lot of time and frustration.

So the more you pack, the more you'll benefit from these front pockets. Another thing makes the AG 65 option a better suited alternative for long lasting trips.

Is anything else any different?

No. Comfort, adjustability and ventilation are all the same and top-notch.


Here's a good review of Atmos AG 65:

That of Aura AG 65:

Atmos AG 50:

Filed Under: Backpacks Tagged With: backpacks, osprey, osprey backpacking backpacks

Osprey Exos vs Atmos

Last updated: August 6, 2021 by Canberk Koksal

As you most of you know I've been talking about Osprey backpacks a lot for years now (see full post list at the bottom), and get this question asked a lot. So here you go.

Atmos AG 65. Hands down the best backpacking backpack in my opinion.

You can think of Osprey's Atmos as their main multi-day backpacking backpack line, whereas the Exos as their main light multi-day backpacking backpack line.

In summary, I think that in many cases; unbeatable comfort, organization and adjustability benefits of Atmos AG 50 and 65 outweigh the price and weight reductions you get with Exos 48 and 58.

Atmos is also considered prettier. This Abyss Grey color is especially liked by many - including me.

  • #A sidenote here: REI's backpack capacity chart is GOLD. Highly recommend you to check it out before you read any further. 
Differences between Exos and Atmos lines can be simplified into this:

  • Atmos line is ridiculously more comfortable (especially the AG 65), much more adjustable, more durable and offers more compartments, accesses & pockets
  • Exos line is MUCH (around 2 lbs) lighter (depending on the size)

Most of you probably read this post to see if it's worth the price reduction you get with the Exos. As you'll see, I believe that it doesn't (at least for most of us).

This is why I recommend the Atmos AG 65 to almost anyone looking for a multi-day backpacking backpack. You can see this in my best Osprey multi-day backpacking backpack as well as best overall hiking backpack posts. 

  • If you're looking for a non-ultralight, budget alternative pack to the Atmos...

...then you should not check out the Osprey Exos, but the Volt. 

I've selected it as the top alternative to Atmos in my Best Osprey Backpacking Backpacks post.  

If you're torn between getting the 50 liter option or the 65 liter option, I also published a post comparing Atmos/Aura's 50 and 65 liter options, so you can check that out.

In summary, I'd recommend you the 65 L.

Osprey Packs Atmos AG 65 Men's Backpacking Backpack
4 Reviews
Osprey Packs Atmos AG 65 Men's Backpacking Backpack
Buy on Amazon
 

If you think you'd be just fine with a 50 liter pack, then I think Atmos AG 50 can be an overkill more often than not. You'd be perfectly fine with Stratos 50.

Osprey Stratos 50 Men's Backpacking Backpack
485 Reviews
Osprey Stratos 50 Men's Backpacking Backpack
  • Incredibly comfortable and ventilated tensioned...
  • Stow-on-the-Go trekking pole attachment
  • Integrated raincover
  • Internal hydration reservoir sleeve
  • Removable top-lid with zippered slash pocket
Buy on Amazon

If you're reading this post looking for a budget multi-day backpacking pack alternative to Atmos, then I'd recommend you to check out Volt (NOT EXOS).

Osprey Volt 75 Men's Backpacking Backpack
Osprey Volt 75 Men's Backpacking Backpack
Buy on Amazon
Osprey Volt 60 Men's Backpacking Backpack
Osprey Volt 60 Men's Backpacking Backpack
(88)
Buy on Amazon

If you're shorter than, say, 5'1"; or taller than, say, 6'6"; then Volt would even feel more comfortable than the Atmos AG 65 thanks to its incredible adjustability. 

Now let's get to the bolts and nuts of these packs.

Comfort

As you some of you might already know, I'm a huge fan of Atmos line - especially the AG 65.

Atmos AG 50.

AG stands for "Anti Gravity" here - the most recent suspension mesh technology of Osprey. 

It helps the backpanel of the backpack float away from your back rather than leaning to it. 

This does not only boost the comfort significantly, but it also keeps you much more ventilated and hence less sweaty along the trail. 

This is kind of ridiculous if you ask me. I remember being blown away the first time I’ve heard about it. Osprey took the game to a whole another level in today's world.

This is why it's called Anti-Gravity. 

The Exos line, on the other hand, is also pretty comfortable when you compare it to the other packs in the market, but definitely not as much as the Atmos. 

Actually, nowhere even near.

Because, in addition to AG technology, the shoulder straps and hipbelt of Atmos Series are generously padded without worrying about weight too much. 

Sleeping Bag Compartments and Accesses

Another shortcoming you should take into consideration with the Exos 48/58 is that they don't offer a sleeping bag compartment at the bottom.

Stretch mesh side pockets available in all Exos and Atmos models offer side access as well - which enables the access on the go. This is a shared feature.

Storing your sleeping bag at the bottom of your pack doesn't require a separate compartment or zipper at the bottom. 

This is why some people feel like this is all gimmicks - although I disagree.

I still find it worthwhile, especially for, say, 40-45+ L packs. I have two reasons for this:

  1. Digging through (or worse, emptying out) your entire inventory in order to get to the bottom of your sleeping bag (or any other item for that matter) to reach an item that is stuck at the very bottom of your pack is far from ideal.
  2. Having a separate compartment at the bottom isn't the only objective advantage you get with Atmos packs. The divider between main and sleeping bag compartments is removable and floating, so it also grants you an additional, easy access to the main compartment from the other side (bottom) as well.

In the end, for these two reasons, a sleeping bag compartment is likely to spare you a fair amount of time and frustration.

A sleeping bag compartment & extra access wouldn't come equally useful for packs with lower volumes, such as Exos 38.

You can dig through your stuff with ease and hence you're less likely to wish having an extra access.

Pockets

My another beef with Exos line is the lack of hipbelt pockets. 

The main advantage of Exos 58 is its ultralight construction.

This implicitly forces you to use the pockets of your clothing for all the items you'd like to have readily available such as snacks, smartphones, wallets, or hand warmers etc.

Becomes a real problem during winter, trips with kids and/or pets, extended trips, etc.

Atmos packs, on the other hand, do offer more storage via hipbelt pockets.

Adjustability

Two adjustments Atmos provides and Exos doesn't:

  1. So called "fit on the fly" hipbelt allows dialing in the right hipbelt fit when you're wearing the pack. It offers up to 6 inches of adjustment.
  2. Shoulder straps are also adjustable for 4 inches.

These take the already superior comfort of Atmos and bring it somewhere unbeatable.

Conclusion

Most of you probably read this post to see if it's worth the price reduction you get with the Exos. As you'll see, I believe that it doesn't (at least for most of us).

This is why I recommend the Atmos AG 65 to almost anyone looking for a multi-day backpacking backpack.

Osprey Packs Atmos AG 65 Men's Backpacking Backpack
4 Reviews
Osprey Packs Atmos AG 65 Men's Backpacking Backpack
Buy on Amazon
 

If you tend to pack lighter and/or go on shorter trips, then I'd surprise you and recommend Stratos 50. 

Osprey Stratos 50 Men's Backpacking Backpack
485 Reviews
Osprey Stratos 50 Men's Backpacking Backpack
  • Incredibly comfortable and ventilated tensioned...
  • Stow-on-the-Go trekking pole attachment
  • Integrated raincover
  • Internal hydration reservoir sleeve
  • Removable top-lid with zippered slash pocket
Buy on Amazon

If you're an ultralighter, then Exos is a better choice for you. You can check out my Osprey Exos 48 vs 58 post to decide the volume. 

Osprey Exos 48 Men's Backpacking Backpack
Osprey Exos 48 Men's Backpacking Backpack
Buy on Amazon
Osprey Exos 58 Men's Backpacking Backpack
Osprey Exos 58 Men's Backpacking Backpack
Buy on Amazon

The best alternative to Exos would probably be Levity - its even lighter cousin (lightest in Osprey's entire backpacking backpack product line). 

Osprey Levity 45L Men's Ultralight Backpacking Backpack,...
Osprey Levity 45L Men's Ultralight Backpacking Backpack,...
  • Lightweight 45 liter backpacking pack built for...
  • Fixed top lid with zippered pockets for organizing...
  • Bellowed front fabric stores rain gear for easy...
  • Internal main compartment compression strap and...
  • 3.5mm Lightwire internal frame and 3D-tensioned...
Buy on Amazon

Filed Under: Backpacks Tagged With: backpacks, osprey, osprey backpacking backpacks

Hiking Carrier for 4 Year Old: You’ll both LOVE these! (Jun 2020)

Last updated: August 19, 2022 by Canberk Koksal

At 4 years old, your child is no longer a toddler but not quite old enough to explore fully on their own. It's sometimes somewhat "tricky".

They want to do it “by themselves” but their little legs also tire easily, and at this age, it's not so easy to throw them up on your shoulders for a rest or carry them in a small baby carrier. 

They can’t do a whole hike on their own two feet. They will need rest a little too often. For this reason, I've gathered some information about the child carrier backpacks (so called hiking carriers) specifically for 4 year olds.

  • Quick answer

My top 3 picks are:

  • Best overall: Osprey Poco AG Plus
  • Best for bigger 4 year olds: Deuter Kid Comfort 3
  • Top alternative to these two: PiggyBack Rider Scout

Also see:

REI's top choices for baby carriers (although their picks AREN'T for FOUR year olds specifically) here: https://www.rei.com/blog/hike/best-baby-carrier-backpacks

Our average 4-year-old weighs 40 pounds and is 40 inches tall. It can be tiring to carry a 40 pound ‘sack of potatoes’ along the trail for most of us.

And by the time they're 5, they may weigh 50 pounds or more, depending on their height and build - which means that it becomes impossible for them to fit inside ANY hiking carrier.

Things to consider

First of all, know that they will want to hike too. Four-year-olds are independent and they can hike for short periods of time on their own. Chances are your four-year-old goes to school and they're likely already familiar with carrying a backpack.

Table of Contents
Things to consider
Osprey Poco AG Plus Review
Deuter Kid Comfort 3 Review
PiggyBack Rider Scout Review
References

On the trail - they might want to be just like the adults - carrying their own little backpack. If that's the case for you, you probably don't want to purchase another small pack solely for this purpose.

None of the three hiking carriers I review in this article come with a removable day pack that your child can wear while walking which then zips on to the child carrier when they're being carried. But, the premium version of best overall pick, Osprey Poco AG Plus, which is Osprey Poco AG Premium does come with one.

Choosing the right child carrier is important because four-year-olds aren’t light. You want the one comfortable for your child AND comfortable for you to carry them for miles on the trail. I'd recommend Deuter Kid Comfort 3 if you'll be hiking longer distances with bigger 4 year olds (more than 40 lbs) - which, I'll review in detail under this post.

Speaking of which, if you don't really know how long you can/will/should hike, my hiking distance and time basics article can be helpful for you.

  • Carrying an extra 40 lbs (on average) can be challenging for less experienced hikers and can decrease your pace significantly

Be sure you're capable of carrying your child for the required distance, should they happen to need it, before setting out on the trail. You may also require some practice adjusting to carrying a child on your back. Hiking with a child carrier can throw off your balance, so it is not recommended for steep ascents or descents.

In the end, I'd recommend these two models and an alternative to regular child carriers which work pretty well for carrying a 4 year old:

Osprey Poco AG Plus

Deuter Kid Comfort 3

PiggyBack Rider SCOUT

Overall Score

88/100
78/100
69/100

Osprey Poco AG Plus

Deuter Kid Comfort 3

PiggyBack Rider SCOUT

Bottom line

Best overall

Best one for bigger & heavier 4 year olds

Best one for longest use (even when they turn 5) and the most versatile one - but only for short hikes

Osprey Poco AG Plus

Deuter Kid Comfort 3

PiggyBack Rider SCOUT

Pros

Comfortable, highly adjustable, tons of storage space, sunshade, stirrups help keep circulation in your kid's legs (and they can play ‘horsey’)

Great for larger hikers, kickstand is great for loading/unloading, drool pillow, easy side loading option is great for a bigger 4 year old

4 year olds love it (especially boys), lightweight, small, can still be used when they turn 5, great for using off the trail too

Cons

Sunshade can get stuck, very tall may not fit well, the waist pocket can't fit bigger phones (iPhone Plus models)

Can’t reach water bottle while pack is worn, not for folks under 5’3”, worse ventilation, can be overkill

4 year olds can't nap in it, less comfortable (unless you purchase the optional hip belt), no storage for gear

Osprey Poco AG Plus

Deuter Kid Comfort 3

PiggyBack Rider SCOUT

Specs

Pack Weight: 6.86 (7.69 lbs)

Maximum Load: 48.5 lbs

Gear Capacity: 20 (26L)

Pack Weight: 7.71 lbs 

Maximum Load: 48.5 lbs

Gear Capacity: 18L

Pack Weight: 2.3 lbs

Maximum Load: 50 lbs

Gear Capacity: n/a

Fit

Hip-belt Fits: 26"– 48"

Torso Fits: 15.5" – 21.5”

Hip-belt Fits: 24"– 54"

Torso Fits: 15" – 21”

N/A

Osprey Poco AG Plus

Deuter Kid Comfort 3

PiggyBack Rider SCOUT

User Manuals

Product Manual [PDF]

Product Manual [PDF]

N/A

Osprey Poco AG Plus Review

This carrier comes in three variations: Standard, Plus, and Premium (although Osprey are no longer producing the premium version, you can still purchase it online from some retailers).

The AG stands for ‘Anti-Gravity’ and Osprey has incorporated their famous backpacking technology into this child carrier to help lighten your load. Even the basic version of this pack has all the bells and whistles. Designed for both safety and comfort, all of the Poco AG carriers have the following features:

  • A mesh suspension system to stabilize the carrier
  • Built in sunshade (removable)
  • Lightweight aluminum frame for stability with locking foot bar (for setting pack down)
  • Mesh back panel for comfort and ventilation
  • Lots of storage (large zippered pocket and accessible stretchy side pockets)
  • Rescue whistle
  • Washable, padded drool pad
  • Fleece covered child harness and comfortable padded child seat with stirrups
  • Reinforced handles for lifting pack
  • Adjustable torso for different heights of adults
  • Pocket for hydration bladder (not included)
  • Listen up Californians

Osprey Poco AG Models mentioned in this review can expose you to chemicals including dimethylformamide, which is known to the State of California to cause cancer. Click here for more information.

Available on the Plus and Premium models (and NOT the base model):

  • An easily adjustable harness and hipbelt to fit a wide range of adult sizes
  • More stash pockets
  • Removable daypack (*PREMIUM ONLY)

This comfortable pack has a maximum weight capacity of 48.5lbs (22kg) so can easily handle the load of an average 4-year-old. Keep in mind, though, that this is the maximum packed weight including pack and gear - so it can carry a 40lb child without gear.

Make sure to weigh the pack, fully loaded with your child and gear, to make sure it doesn't exceed the limit. 

Now the pros and cons - but more detailed than the table above:

PROS:

  • Easy to strap in child
  • Kids love being up high to see
  • Highly adjustable for all heights of adults (can easily switch to be carried by a short and tall person while on the trail)
  • Tons of storage space (can fit almost everything besides tent/sleeping bag)
  • Kickstand keeps pack upright for loading
  • Easy to adjust on the go (the plus and premium model has a ‘fit on the fly’ hipbelt)
  • Pack feels heavy to lift but does not feel heavy while wearing it
  • Sunshade (and optional raincover) offers ample protection from the elements
  • Stirrups help keep circulation in child’s legs (and they can play ‘horsey’!)
  • Removable daypack is perfect for child’s backpack while they are walking (*available with premium model)

CONS:

  • Sunshade can get stuck sometimes
  • Taller children may not fit well in the cockpit
  • Some people find the hip belt uncomfortable and hard to distribute weight on hips
  • The waist pocket is not big enough to fit a phone
  • The shoulder pad felt too thin to some users
  • Hydration pocket can snag
    despite adjustments, some shorter hikers found this pack uncomfortable at their head and lower back

Overall, the Osprey Poco AG is probably the best overall hiking carrier for a 4 year old.

Osprey Poco AG Plus Child Carrier, Seaside Blue, (Prior...
272 Reviews
Osprey Poco AG Plus Child Carrier, Seaside Blue, (Prior...
  • A lightweight aluminum frame fully supports the...
  • With 6 inch/15cm of torso adjustment, the poco ag...
  • The adjustable double halo harness and child seat...
  • The built-in sunshade deploys quickly and easily...
  • The adjustable fit-on-the-fly hip belt offers 5...
Buy on Amazon

Poco AG Plus doesn't come with a removable day pack that your child can wear while walking (which then zips on to the child carrier for when they're being carried), so if that's important for you, check out the Premium Model:

Osprey Poco AG Premium Child Carrier, Blue, One Size
42 Reviews
Osprey Poco AG Premium Child Carrier, Blue, One Size
Buy on Amazon

The Premium DOES come with a removable day pack. Everything else is pretty much the same for these two models.

Deuter Kid Comfort 3 Review

Another great option is the Deuter Kid Comfort III Child Carrier. This carrier comes highly equipped with rave reviews. Deuter offers a few levels of child carriers. Their Air model is the most lightweight and offers great ventilation for hot climates, however it's a smaller pack with less load capacity so not ideal for carrying older children.

The Kid Comfort III is their most spacious and well-outfitted pack, making it ideal for long hikes and larger 4 year olds. Deuter has an excellent safety record and their high quality packs exceed the required standards, going through extensive testing by the Juvenile Products Manufacturers Association.

The Deuter Kid Comfort III has the following features:

  • Five point safety harness (similar to a car seat harness)
  • Customizable fit for different heights/torsos
  • Side and top entry points
  • Height adjustable seat for different sizes of children
  • Aircomfort ventilation system (to help keep your back cool)
  • Retractable sunroof
  • Grab handles for picking up pack
  • Removable, washable padded chin pad
  • Foot stirrups
  • Rearview mirror
  • Hydration pocket (fits 3L water bladder, not included)
  • Flexible, padded, adjustable hip belt with Vari Flex hip fins (helps keep balance)

This pack is ideal for carrying larger 4 year olds, as it's spacious and adjustable. Making it even more ideal is the Aircontact and Vari Flex technology that allows you to adjust your load evenly. Deuter has created a pack that can handle going down stairs and steep, uneven terrain even while carrying a heavy load.

Their design allows the pack to sit close to your back and centre of gravity to that it stays as stable as possible. The carrier is well-padded for both children and parents, making for a comfortable ride on long hikes. In one test, it scored 9/10 for child comfort (the highest of all reviewed packs) and scored 8/10 for parent comfort.

For long hikes, the Deuter Kid Comfort III is my top pick!

PROS:

  • Hipbelt fits wide range of sizes, great for larger hikers
  • Distributes weight well, even on more aggressive terrain with older child - easy to keep balance even with heavy load
  • Very comfortable for kids and the adults who carry them
  • Child feels very secure with easy-to-use five point harness (even when bending over, child is safe)
  • Kickstand great for loading/unloading
    some people found this carrier more comfortable than the Osprey Poco AG
  • Drool pillow is comfy for kids to fall asleep (and removes easily to wash)
  • Easy side loading option and adjustable harness is great for bigger kids
  • High backrest allows kids to sleep easily and is an added safety feature in case of fall

CONS:

  • Can’t reach water bottle while pack is worn
  • Some shorter hikers found the pack too large and were unable to adjust the fit properly (especially those under 5’3”)
  • Some adults found the chest strap uncomfortable
  • Can get sweaty on long hikes (Kid Comfort Air has better ventilation but less premium features)
  • Can be overkill
  • Pack can tip over when child is in it, even with kickstand in use - never leave a child unattended while in the pack

For the longer hikes with bigger 4 year olds, Deuter Kid Comfort III is probably your best choice.

Deuter Kid Comfort III Framed Hiking Child Carrier for...
94 Reviews
Deuter Kid Comfort III Framed Hiking Child Carrier for...
  • Kid Comfort 3-Black Granite
  • Kid Comfort 3-Black Granite
  • Deuter
  • Kid Comfort 3 Child Carrier
Buy on Amazon

Product Video:

PiggyBack Rider Scout Review

As you see, this is an alternate model to more regular designs of previous 2 hiking carriers.

How to get on.

Finally, I'll to tell you about the PiggyBack Rider Scout Child Carrier. Invented by two brothers, this carrier is excellent for 4 year old kids as it was designed specifically for the creator’s 4-year-old son.

While not a traditional child carrier, the Piggyback Rider is a unique design that is an alternative to… you guessed it… a piggyback. Kids love the Piggyback Rider because they are up high and can take in all the sights.

This carrier has received a lot of media attention and endorsements for its innovative design. You'll likely get a lot of attention from people on the trail who want to know where you got it (not necessarily because you want that attention, haha).

How to get off.

With the PiggyBack Rider, your 4-year-old is attached to a harness and they stand up on a bar that runs across your back. There are handholds on the shoulder for them to hold onto during the ride.

The PiggyBack Rider doesn't have any storage space, so it isn't ideal if you're hiking on your own; however, if you're just doing a short hike or hiking with a group, the PiggyBack rider can be pretty good.

It's also very light at only 2.3 lbs and easy to carry when not in use (it rolls up as small as a towel), unlike the bulkier alternatives out there. It can accommodate children up to 50 lbs. 

The original model is quite basic, but you can purchase additional features, such as a hipbelt, water bottle holder, pockets, etc. You can also purchase a child’s backpack, which fits a 1L hydration bladder, which they can wear while hiking or riding on your back.

PROS:

  • 4 year olds love riding and being up high in the PiggyBack Rider (especially boys) 
  • lightweight and packs up small, easy to carry or store in backpack when not using
    affordable
  • easy for child to balance and hold on 
  • can still be used when they turn 5
  • great for using off the trail too - at the zoo, grocery store, etc. 

CONS:

  • If child is tired, they can’t nap while using the PiggyBack Rider as they have to stand
  • Can put a lot of weight on shoulders as doesn’t distribute weight to hips (unless you purchase the optional hip belt)
  • Bar can bump against bum/lower back of adult, which can cause discomfort over time
  • No storage for gear
  • Additional features must be purchased separately

For the most versatile use with short hikes, PiggyBack Rider Scout can be your best choice.

Piggyback Rider Toddler Carrier Backpack - Scout Standing...
1,108 Reviews
Piggyback Rider Toddler Carrier Backpack - Scout Standing...
  • Bundle of Safe, Whimsical Fun: Our backpack...
  • Elevate Outdoor Bonding: Buckle up for thrills...
  • Carry Comfortably: Create memories and share...
  • Crafted for Epic Adventures: Our lightweight...
  • Our Pledge: As a family-owned and operated...
$154.99
Buy on Amazon

Product Video:


I hope this review was helpful for you to understand which child carrier backpack for a 4 year old is the best one for your needs. Feel free to ask me any questions, provide feedback and I'll be happy to respond in the comment section below if it's within my knowledge. 

Thanks a lot for reading. Happy trails.

Filed Under: Backpacks Tagged With: carrier, hiking, kids

  • « Go to Previous Page
  • Go to page 1
  • Go to page 2
  • Go to page 3
  • Go to page 4
  • Go to page 5
  • Interim pages omitted …
  • Go to page 7
  • Go to Next Page »

Primary Sidebar

Crunch Search

About me

Hey, what's up? Canberk here. A former General Electric Aviation Design Engineer. Academically involved in cold weather outdoor gear, particularly wearable heating systems using conductive polyester and polyamide yarns. Read more about me.

  • Email
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • LinkedIn

Featured Posts

  • Temperature Ratings of Insulated Jackets
  • Best Arc’teryx Jackets
  • Best Patagonia Jackets

window.dataLayer = window.dataLayer || []; function gtag(){dataLayer.push(arguments);} gtag('js', new Date()); gtag('config', 'G-GDD0YD30SK');

  • BASICS
  • PRO TIPS
  • GEAR
  • MISCELLANEOUS
  • ABOUT
  • PRIVACY POLICY